Emma’s War, Deborah Scroggins

2015-02-07 17.02.51A few years ago, my parents (in a fit of madness) moved to South Sudan. They were going to spend two years working in the local government education department of a South Sudanese town called Rumbek. When they went, they left me with this book which they said provided a great overview of the history of South Sudan.  At the time, I knew very little about South Sudan, and none of it very reassuring. I took the decision that probably the less I knew about South Sudan, the better, otherwise I might not sleep for the full two years until they got back.  They were evacuated from South Sudan just over a year ago, when the country fell back into civil war.

So, as they were no longer there, I felt able to read this brilliant book and, I have to say, I am very glad I did not read it while Mum and Dad were there.  Emma’s War charts the history of conflict and humanitarian aid in Sudan starting in the late 19th century, but then really focussing on the 1980s and 1990s.  Officially, the book tells the story of Emma McCune, a British aid worker who married the charming and deadly Sudanese warlord, Riek Machar, and lived with him, often in the wildest parts of Sudan, until her death in 1993, but in reality it is much more wide-ranging.

Through Emma’s story Scroggins is able to explain the tensions inherent in providing aid to third world

The town of Rumbek, South Sudan

The town of Rumbek, South Sudan

countries and how aid relief is politicised and rarely gets to the people it is intended for.  We are also able to follow some of the political infighting within the southern Sudanese SPLA (Sudan People’s Liberation Army) and between the various SPLA leaders and the northern Sudanese government. We learn about the endemic trade in slaves and the use of famine as a weapon of war.  Scroggins has a real talent in explaining the very complex world of Sudanese loyalties and the impact that they have on the lives of people in Sudan.  I loved this paragraph from early in the book which, for me, really captures why conflict in Sudan feels so inevitable and impossible to stop.

I have often thought that you need a …layered map to understand Sudan’s civil war.  A surface map of political conflict, for example – the northern government versus the southern rebels; and under that a layer of religious conflict – Muslim versus Christian and pagan; and under that a map of all the sectarian divisions within those categories; and under that a layer of ethnic division – Arab and Arabised versus Nilotic and Equatorian – all of them containing a multitude of clan and tribal subdivisions; and under that a layer of linguistic conflicts; and under that a layer of economic divisions – the more developed North with fewer natural resources versus the poorer South with rich mineral and fossil fuel deposits; and under that a layer of colonial divisions; and under that a layer of racial divisions related to slavery. And so on and so on until it would become clear that the war, like the country, was not one, but many: a violent ecosystem capable of generating endless new things to fight about without shedding any of the old ones.

This book is not just a story of political and military conflict, is also a fascinating story of how a young idealistic woman, who was drawn to the Sudan by an almost missionary zeal help, and a fierce love of adventure, ended up marrying a warlord who, in many respects, was undermining everything she had been working towards.  Scroggins has done a huge amount of research for her book and she portrays a very nuanced view of Emma and her thoughts and actions.  She also shares a lot of the controversy that surrounded Emma with public and private opinion, both in the UK and Sudan being wildly split.  I think she also captures the sense that it is very hard to understand the truth of what happens during war, and that it is impossible for anyone to come out of it with their morality in tact.

Tea ladies at the Rumbek Ministry of Education

Tea ladies at the Rumbek Ministry of Education

For me though, some of the most powerful elements were actually Scroggins sharing her own experiences of being a reporter in Sudan.  Her descriptions of the famine in Safaha were harrowing, and all the more heartbreaking for the senseless greed that was fuelling a lot of them.  Her story also gives a sense of the challenges she faced as a journalist in understanding and negotiating her way through this complex country.

I would really highly recommend that you read Emma’s War, but despite being brilliantly written, it is not a cheering read. By the end of the book you really understand the bitter hopelessness in the Sudanese saying “When God made Sudan, He laughed”.

Emma’s War, Deborah Scroggins, Harper Collins, 2004

2 thoughts on “Emma’s War, Deborah Scroggins

  1. Emma’s husband, Riek Machar, is the man who became Vice President of South Sudan at independence. It was his sacking in 2013 that led to fighting in December of that year. which descended into the major conflict that still hasn’t been resolved. I think that the description of the multiple layers involved in the conflict sums up the problem well.

    There are also the ongoing problems due to the fragmentation of children’s education, e.g poor literacy and numeracy, lack of vocational training, the lack of conflict resolution skills, violence against women…

    Perhaps I should re-read the book.


  2. Pingback: Well, that was February! | Blogging Around My Bookcase

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s