A fine balance, Rohinton Mistry

mistryI think the phrase “rollercoaster of emotion” was invented specifically for this book.  As I write these words, having just finished the book, I am a bit of an emotional wreck.  I was given this book for free as part of World Book Night in 2011 and, although I had started it, I had never made it all the way through before.  I’m not sure why not because it is brilliantly written and the characters are fantastic.

The book follows the stories of four main characters, with a great cast of sub characters that drift in and out throughout the story.  The first is Dina Dalal, a woman determined to make her way independently in the world in spite of the difficulties and family pressures she faces.  The second are two tailors, gentle Ishvar and his sweet but a bit rebellious nephew Omprakash who move to the big city in hope of work and fleeing a brutal caste system in the countryside. And the final member of the quartet is a young student called Maneck sent by his parents from the hills to the city to study refrigeration.  The lives of the four intertwine through the book and this unusual ‘family’ provides much of the fleeting joy in the book.

It is really hard to write about this without spoiling the plot, but all four of them live their lives on a knife-edge between survival and disaster.  There is a poignant comment from a lawyer about 200 pages in:

Sometimes you have to use your failures as stepping-stones to success.  You have to maintain a fine balance between hope and despair.

It really sums up the book.  You realise how whimsical the things that affect people’s lives can be.  The book, set in Bombay during the Emergency called by Indira Gandhi, also captures how the corrupt nature of the government makes people at the lower ends of society so vulnerable, and the awful things that powerful people can do when there is nobody to stop them. Mistry clearly evokes life on the margins of society; the beggars and the street-sleepers, come alive in his hands.  It is telling that one of the most likeable characters in the book is the beggarmaster who essentially is running a protection racket where people pay him in return for his ‘protection’.  It is ridiculous that when he appears in the story you feel such a sense of relief that he can bring a measure of safety to the characters rather than feeling horror that they are having to pay to remain unmolested.

The book centres around the four characters as the tailors work to fulfil orders for a clothing export company.  This leads to lots of thread related metaphors and one of my favourite parts of the book was when they examine the quilt Dina has been making from scraps of cloth throughout the story and each piece of cloth relates to an experience they have all had together.  Life’s rich tapestry brought to life.

The book is particularly damning of the cruelty and unfairness of the caste system, the slum clearances and the government’s scheme to enforce birth control measures on an unwilling population. Indeed, Indira Gandhi gets a really bad press – the scenes in which Om and Ishvar are captured and taken to a political rally and ordered to cheer are funny but awful. The police are viewed as weak and impotent, the legal system a mockery. Against this precarious background the lives of our four characters teeter.  The moments of joy and security feel incredibly precious.  There is a moment, about 400 pages in that feels very much like a happy ending, and yet you know that because of the remaining 200 pages, this happiness can’t last.  And it really doesn’t last.  The final third of the book is brutal, shattering and painful as everything is unwound.  As I read the final words, I looked up at E and said “We are very lucky”.

4 thoughts on “A fine balance, Rohinton Mistry

  1. I’m really pleased you enjoyed this one, though that might be the wrong word. I hated it! 😉 I abandoned it at the halfway point on the grounds that it was just unrelievedly miserable. I felt he was just piling it on to an extent where it was impossible to believe – these four poor people getting every single bad thing that has happened in India for forty years dumped on their heads. I think the crunch point was the dog – as soon as it appeared I thought ‘Oh dear!’ and sure enough – no happy ending for the pooch! The writing was good though…

    I’m also incredibly impressed at how quickly you read it!


    • I agree it is pretty miserable, which may be why I gave up first time around. But, not long after the dog episode it does actually cheer up and is almost warm and cosy for a bit. That said, if you thought that it was miserable at the dog point, that is nothing compared to what happens in the last 200 pages. Misery upon misery. And it was worse, I think, because they had all had an interlude of happiness and hope.

      I’ve got a lot of very long books facing me in the next few months so I’m going to have to do some extreme speed reading, I fear!


      • Yes, I flicked through to the end to see if by any chance Cinderella made it to the ball. Nope! I bet she got run over by the carriage and jilted by the Prince…


  2. I loved this book. I read it over eight years ago, but the emotional impact has stayed with me. The characters are so vividly drawn and it is so beautifully written and that starkly contrasts with the stark brutality of the novel. I’ll definitely reread it at some point.


Leave a Reply to FictionFan Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s